Rev. John F. Broyles was elected pastor during the church’s fifth anniversary. Under Rev. Broyles leadership, the church grew physically and spiritually, which would prompt an expansion to the sanctuary and annex of the Oxford Street location in 1913.

In 1917, Rev. J.F. Broyles would step down after falling terminally ill. Rev. Charles H. Walton would step in as Interim Pastor for one year.

After Rev. Walton's Interim and Rev. Broyles death, Rev. William M. Winfrey accepted the pastoral call in 1918.

During Winfrey's leadership, membership would increase and a building expansion would take place onto the Oxford St. location.

After ten years of serving as Pastor, Rev. Winfrey would step down. 

In 1928, Rev. Charles Walton would become the pastor of Mt. Carmel for 17 years. Great strides were taking under his ministry of redecorating and tackling the debt of the Oxford location.

Rev. Walton was called from labor to reward in 1945 and a small host of ministers would fill the gap of a leader.

After Rev. Walton's passing, Rev. Philander Oldham who was a minister of Mt. Carmel Church would be offered the position of pastor until 1946.

Mississippi-born, Hoosier transplant Rev. A.D. Banks, would accept pastoral leadership.

During the Banks years, the congregation would double in growth, multiple ministries were added that heading repairs on the Oxford location.

Rev. Banks would lead the congregation until 1953 as he would be called to pastor another congregation.

After Rev. Banks' departure, Rev. James Glover became pastor.

Nineteen ministries would continue to nourish under Glover with the assistance of multiple dedicated deacons and ministers.

Rev. Glover would serve the Mt. Carmel Church until 1962.

Rev. Dr. Taft Talmadge "T.T." Newman by way of Marion, Indiana would be called to the Mt. Carmel Church.

In 19 Dr. Newman deemed "The Vision" of moving to a new sanctuary as Mt. Carmel continued to outgrew their E. 25th Street location.

 would move to a newly built edifice at 5502 E. 36th Street. After pastoring for almost 25 years at Mt. Carmel, Rev. T.T. Newman was called to his heavenly home in January of  1987.

Soon after his passing, a search committee was formed and the search for a new pastor would begin soon after.

Rev. Dr. Theron D. Williams would accept pastoral leadership of the church. Since then, the Lord has added many souls to the body of Christian believers at Mt. Carmel Church.

Pastor Williams through his anointed preaching and teaching ability has been a source of strength, inspiration, and encouragement to a great number of newly ordained and experienced ministers preaching the word of God.

Within the first few years, A new building expansion deemed the "Gymnatorium" due to its ability to be used for multi-purpose events, was built onto the E. 36th Street location soon after mortgage burning and would open soon thereafter.

Radio and television ministries were established, and the congregation grew to proportions that necessitated three services—two on Sunday and one on Wednesday night.

Due to increasing membership, multiple services, and new ministries being developed around the area, a new location was in consideration. After heavy consecration, prayer, and faith, A plot of land close to the city limits East of Indianapolis would be purchased on E. 42nd St. for future development and ministry reach.

Though this great investment was made, there was still the need for a new sanctuary. Hence came the unique opportunity to build onto a former school at 4352 N. Mitthoefer Rd.

In July of 1999, Mt. Carmel would walk in to their new sanctuary with great anticipation going into the 21st century.
During these next several years, our ministries would develop into a central hub for community and growth.

After just over a decade of continued ministry on Mitthoefer, the next chapter would be written just around the corner.